[HusarDerLuft]

personally, i believe the 51 is better than them all, but, it is a bit biased, since i am part of a 51 dedicated squad, but it has its limits, since ive been able to shoot down many squadmates in either the ki84 and fw190, so it all depends on you.

I agree, its not so much the plane but the pilot that makes the difference.. Thats why this is a hard poll - the planes are almost equally matched
Personally I would have flown the 190A8, my fav.