[Saburo Sakai]

"Experimental?" maybe. there where many planes that made flights but did not get into service, so why not indeed.

"What if?" i am TOTALLY against.
what if the germans invented the death star ? or laser weapons ? see my point, what if holds no boundaries and would kill the sim by turning it into a farce of spaceships and such. if you want sci fi planes, go play star trek or something.

"the game engine makes it possible....." so what, the game engine makes it possible to race bikes, and add the x-wing star fighter, but would you want to do that il2 !

then there is the old, "its up to the modellers what they make........". too true, but i would hope that the modellers would see the sense of not wanting to destroy the game by adding over the top planes that dont belong in a ww2 sim, for that is what this is really, a ww2 sim, well thats why i bought it, to fly ww2 prop planes. i have falcon4 af and lomac for jets and blackshark for helos.

There will always be people to argue the for's and against's for this subject so dont bite me for arguing against the what if planes, it is after all, just a discussion.

:wink:

That was most non-sense silly thing I ever heard... "Star Trek" and "Star War' never have something to do with this, when it come to determining 'predicted' flight model for alternative historical aircraft in most realistic way possible. The point of this debates is about adding experimental and 'what if' aircraft based on documents of an aeronautical that officially design the aircraft that have not made it past to prototype stages. There is no such thing as 'star trek' and 'star war' non-sense in this. REMEMBER if you don't want to fly these alternative historical planes, you DONT have to fly them nor download these files. I find your posts quite negative and is non-constructive when you stated this:

what if the germans invented the death star ? or laser weapons ? see my point, what if holds no boundaries and would kill the sim by turning it into a farce of spaceships and such. if you want sci fi planes, go play star trek or something.

That was negative and non-constructive statement and I don't appericate it when someone tell me to play these 'sci-fi' when I have stated countless of time that it's about adding 'expimental and 'what if' aircraft in most realistic way witih 'predicted' filght model for IL-2 1946. Besides there was NO laser NOR death star in World War II, including in 'what if' part because German never had plans for these non-sense things.


Chaoic out...

negative, non constructive, nosense and silly, is it really? do you really think that? of course you do, you want to see planes that never existed fly in il2.
it is not silly, what i said was extreme, but it proves that "what if ", as i said, has no boundaries.
i see you did not quote what i said about experimental planes............ i have no problems with them because they did exist, even if it was only on paper, but once you start adding planes that people make up in their own head, thats where the extremities come into play, and before long you WOULD see x-wing fighters and such like. i have seen it happen before and i saw a post on here where there WAS a death star in the game.

viewtopic.php?t=7913&highlight=death+star